CEO Checklist — Is Your Team Playing to Win?
-
Do all interviewers know what success looks like for this hire?
-
Are all candidates being asked consistent, structured questions?
-
Are hiring decisions made using objective criteria?
-
Do managers get feedback and coaching on their interviewing?Would you feel comfortable sitting in on your managers’ interviews today?
You wouldn’t send your team onto the field without a playbook. Imagine a quarterback calling random plays. The receivers don’t know where to run. The linemen miss their blocks. The result? Fumbles. Missed opportunities. Lost games.
Yet that’s exactly how most companies run their interviews — no consistent structure, no alignment on what “winning” looks like, and no system for executing under pressure.
Hiring is a competitive sport. Every bad hire — or slow hire — is lost yardage for your business.
The 3 Big Risks of “Shooting from the Hip” in Interviews
1. No alignment on what “winning” looks like
-
Managers ask random questions
-
No clear scoring system or success profile
-
Candidates get mixed signals → top talent walks away
2. Missed high-potential candidates
-
Unstructured interviews over-focus on charisma or gut feel
-
Undervalued: adaptability, problem-solving, culture fit
-
Result: Your future MVP is on someone else’s team
3. High cost of a bad hire
-
Avg. cost of bad hire = 30% of annual salary (plus hidden costs: team morale, lost customers, leadership distraction)
-
One mishire can throw off an entire division’s momentum
Questions? Contact us today!